lmao!

you cant say that can yu ben?

 

oops you already did! lol

just because a movie doesn't feature a traditional 'happy ending' or even any closure at all, doesn't mean that it's not a movie in it's own right.

 

fellowship, towers and return may be three parts of a greater story but they are, like it or not, three distinct movies.

 

alasdair

im pissed so am going to get possionbly rude.

 

"Like Whatever dude" (major american accent used)

 

ur opinion not mine all i know is wot JRR Tolkien intended 4 book and if he knew limitations of film it wud be wot he intended on the screen.

 

1 book in 3 volumes.

 

So just dont argue back til i can be moer comprehendive, am going out sat nite as well s wait til at least rthursda=y for something worth arguaing aginst on this topics

benrostwood said:

ur opinion not mine all i know is wot JRR Tolkien intended 4 book and if he knew limitations of film it wud be wot he intended on the screen.

 

1 book in 3 volumes.

 

you are totally contradicting yourself. [note to self, must not post when drunk]

 

alasdair